top of page

Proof E. Jean Carroll Lied

  • tatobin4
  • Apr 7, 2024
  • 3 min read

Updated: Sep 28

The claim by E. Jean Carroll that President Trump raped her is simply not credible.


Major Credibility Problems


Carroll’s story mirrors an episode of Law & Order—a show she admits being addicted to. She remained silent for 24 years, only to suddenly come forward just before an election. She also has a long history of politically deranged, Trump-hating posts. Adding to the suspicion, New York Democrats changed the law specifically to allow her case—clear #FakeNews and #WitchHunt territory.

Consider this: Carroll once tweeted that her favorite TV show was The Apprentice hosted by Trump. In what world does someone embrace as their “favorite” a show hosted by the man they claim raped them?

Originally, Carroll admitted she told no one. Later, after that contradiction was noted, she suddenly produced a friend to testify otherwise. Such flip-flopping undercuts credibility.

Outside of a single publicity photo at a public event, there is no evidence she ever personally knew Trump, much less had contact with him.


The Donna Karan Dress Story


Carroll claimed she was wearing a Donna Karan jacket dress during the alleged attack. In her 2019 New York Magazine article, she insisted the incident happened in 1994, even posing in the dress she said she had left untouched in her closet since then. But readers quickly noted that the dress didn’t even exist in 1994.

Carroll then changed her story to 1995—yet the dress still wasn’t available. She changed it again to 1996.

What rape victim “forgets” not just the date, but the year? The hallmark of truth is consistency. Carroll’s story has shifted repeatedly. Further, Bergdorf Goodman dressing rooms are always staffed, according to regular patrons—making her scenario implausible.

Trump maintains detailed daily calendars. Carroll’s refusal to name a date or year effectively deprived him of the ability to provide a defense, while she deceptively used the dress as supposed “evidence.”


Outside Influence and Political Targeting


Carroll initially swore that no one was behind her lawsuit. Later it was revealed she was advised and funded by anti-Trump figures George Conway and Democrat billionaire donor Reid Hoffman.

In response to her accusations, New York Democrats quickly passed the Adult Survivors Act, temporarily removing the statute of limitations for sexual assault lawsuits. This transparent maneuver was clearly political.


Carroll’s Pattern of Accusations


Few know that Carroll has accused at least six other men of assault—including a babysitter’s boyfriend, a dentist, a camp counselor, a college date, a boss, and former CBS chief Les Moonves.

In the Moonves case, she alleged he groped her in an elevator in 1997. He denied it. Given that elevators are short rides, monitored by CCTV, and constantly at risk of stopping, her claim strains belief.


Odd and Troubling Behavior


Carroll has openly called rape “sexy,” and even made an awkward, flirtatious pass at Anderson Cooper while telling her story:🔹 https://rumble.com/v49u40u-e.-jean-carrolls-claim-of-rape-matches-an-episode-of-law-and-order..html

Her at-home interview with Elle magazine also raised questions about her mental stability:🔹 https://rumble.com/v49ukkf-e.-jean-carrolls-at-home-interview-with-elle.html


The Trial Was Flawed


Two juries were involved: the first determined liability, the second damages. The first jury specifically found that Trump did not rape Carroll. Yet the judge misled the second jury, telling them Trump had been found guilty of rape, while preventing Trump’s defense from correcting the record. Here is the first jury’s verdict:🔹 https://x.com/sallyma20250646/status/1751030096264086004?s=20

The judge also gave jurors sweeping instructions that “battery” in a civil case could include anything from an unwanted kiss on the cheek to stabbing someone with a knife:🔹 https://apnews.com/article/trump-rape-trial-explainer-b81969ba9e3cc0406909497f87e9e14c

In a civil trial, the standard is only “more likely than not” (51%). In a criminal trial, the standard would be “beyond a reasonable doubt.” The jury clearly did not believe Carroll’s claims rose to that level.


False “Rape Liability” Headlines


Media outlets often say Trump was found “liable for rape.” This is false. The jury explicitly voted “No” on the question of rape:🔹 https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GIZEnJ4XEAAnrGo?format=png&name=900x900

They found him liable for “sexual assault”—but given the judge’s instructions, that could mean something as trivial as unwanted touching.


Conclusion


Taken together, these facts reveal E. Jean Carroll’s claims to be politically motivated, factually inconsistent, and deeply unreliable. Her story changed multiple times, her supposed evidence doesn’t line up, her lawsuit was fueled by Trump-hating operatives, and the trial itself was tainted.


Donald Trump never raped or assaulted E. Jean Carroll.

Additional links:

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page